Fair disclosure warning: this is my favorite book of all time. And yes, this edition is from 1996, but the book was originally published in 1908. This book is a marvel and a wonder, and if you don't want to read it at least a
little bit it might seriously jeopardize our chances at a long-term friendship. So no pressure, or anything. Side note: it is also directly responsible for my very wonderful relationship. I started reading it aloud to K on our very first date, and by the time we got to chapter three, well...that was it. Furthermore, it should be noted that his extremely epic blond beard and curly mustache both derive directly from the facial hair of the main character of
Thursday. As in I said him, "Hey, so you should probably have a pointed yellow beard like Syme" and then he did. ALL I DO IS WIN.
|
This one. STAY AWAY. |
You may have noticed that I have a thing about which edition I think you should read.This is because it makes a bloody difference, dammit. In this case, the edition I want you to read has several things going for it: a pretty stellar introduction,
really stellar textual notes (which you will need, okay, to understand jokes about stuff that is a
century old) and also two extra short stories at the back, which Chesterton wrote
before he wrote
Thursday, which do a very cool job of illustrating how disparate ideas come together to make something epically awesome and more than the sum of its parts, in this case the topics of God and Anarchy
. If you can't get this Oxford edition, fine; just whatever you do
don't get the f!#&ing Ignatius Press version, with annotations by Martin Gardner, because they are
unbelievably annoying. Gardner apparently saw the book as a chance to write about everything he ever wanted to say about Edwardian England, whether or not it is even remotely relevant; at one point he uses an incidental mention of "gollywog" to go off for two full pages - three if you count the illustration - about the
history of the word, which he begins thusly: "This lengthy note will tell you much more about gollywogs than you may care to know, but I hope you will find it an interesting sidelight on Edwardian England." Yes! That's right! It IS much more than I care to know! IF I WANTED TO READ ABOUT GOLLYWOGS I WOULD HAVE BOUGHT A DIFFERENT BOOK. Also, these are FOOTNOTES, not endnotes, and so the actual text of the story takes up literally
four of the
thirty-two lines on the page,
half the next page, and did I mention the illustration? Oh, I did? Well, anyway, that's the page after that. He does this several times, just wandering off on his own trains of thought, which he seems to find
utterly fascinating, and leaves the actual text of the book to occupy a couple lines at the top of the page as, you know, a special favor. He also plugs his own books, and most of the actually useful footnotes are just quotes from other people's annotations. It is
maddening. I would mind less if the notes were at the back, where they might provide an interesting addition, but having them
in the text makes me want to RIP THE PAGES
.
Oh yeah, and then also? he has GIANT SPOILERS in the footnotes.
Thursday is, among other things, a mystery novel. You know what ruins mystery novels?
GIANT F!#&ING SPOILERS, that's what. And don't even get me
started on the place where he started to go off about how one of Chesterton's images could be taken as a symbol of
string theory. He's like "so I know Chesterton probably didn't intend this, but..." NO SHIT, SHERLOCK. You know what they didn't have in 1908? STRING THEORY. You just wanted to look smart, and instead? You look like a jerk who just likes to see himself talk.
Sigh. Sorry, Mr. Gardener, that was maybe kinda mean and harsh, but
really, dude. Don't do that. Anyway, ladies and germs, your five questions are, as always...
1. Who the f!#& wrote this book?
2. What the f!#& is it about?
3. Where the f!#& should I read this book?
4. When the f!#& is it set?
5.
Why the f!#& should I read it?
Also, I have some fun news about an awesome reading adventure that's starting up later this month, so keep reading, because you too can be a part of
Putting the Blog in Balrog!